Antwort auf: PINK FLOYD – The later years (1987-2019)

#10936779  | PERMALINK

pink-nice3
Ex-Klär-Kanal-Pumpen und Elektrowärter

Registriert seit: 24.06.2016

Beiträge: 7,308

cycleandale

pink-nice3

pink-nice3Freitag kommt schon mal die die Highlights-CD….ich werde berichten. ….

Highlights CD: 01 – Shine on You Crazy Diamond (Live at Knebworth): 11:04 02 – Marooned Jam: 3:16 03 – One Slip (2019 mix): 5:03 04- Loss For Words (tour rehearsal): 5:31 05- Us And Them (DSOT remix): 7:30 06- Comfortably Numb (Live at Knebworth): 7:36 07 – Sorrow (2019 mix): 8:29 08 – Learning to Fly (DSOT remix): 5:25 09- High Hopes (early version): 6:49 10 – On The Turning Away (2019 mix): 5:36 11- Wish you Were Here (Live at Knebworth): 4:39 12- Run Like Hell (DSOT remix): 7:39

Klingt gut. Berichte bitte vor allem mal ob sich die 2019er Mixe der A momentary lapse of reason – Tracks lohnen!

Klingt schon mal nicht so toll auf dem S.Hoffman Forum:

here’s my take on the unreleased songs on the highlights LP:

Shine On (Knebworth) – very good performance and mix. Crystal clear guitar in the beginning, really cool 8/10

Marooned jam – hmm, to be honest, bit disappointed. The jam is good, but the track fades in/out and it just seems a bit out of place. There’s a saying in my country that goes „he came in muted and left in silence“. This is how I feel about this track. The jam available in the Tree of Secrets bootleg is way more interesting. 6/10

Lost for Words – incredible!!!! 10/10

Us and Them (DSOT) – nice intro, good mix. powerful backing vocal during chorus. excellent version 10/10 

CNumb (Knebworth) – nice mix, although I believe David’s guitar should be louder…however…. the final solo is cut short in a very weird way, I absolutely hated it. They cut off the best part, imo. Very weird decision! Big disappointment…. 3/10

Learning to Fly (DSOT) – 5/10 gary wallis’ drums are very dry and the overall mix seems weaker, not as epic as in the original album. Middle section was also shortened, weird decision. Tim renwick’s guitar toned down in the middle section as well. Just sounded a bit weird.

OOTA (remix) – new vocals (?) and drums are very different. Rick’s hammond way more prominent. Interesting mix, however the original version is more powerful, imo 7/10

As a huge floyd fan, I’m kind of worried about the new DSOT and these shortened cuts. There’s simply no reason for this new edit of CNumb. What were they thinking?

Schaun wir mal….???!!!

--

Wenn ich meinen Hund beleidigen will nenne ich ihn Mensch. (AS) „Weißt du, was ich manchmal denke? Es müsste immer Musik da sein. Bei allem was du machst. Und wenn's so richtig Scheiße ist, dann ist wenigstens noch die Musik da. Und an der Stelle, wo es am allerschönsten ist, da müsste die Platte springen und du hörst immer nur diesen einen Moment.“ +27233