Aus dem All Music Guide über die Rhino-Ausgabe:
Just when you thought that the perfect album and its CD equivalent couldn’t get any better, along comes Rhino with this 25-song „Deluxe Edition“ of Dusty in Memphis. The new transfers on the original Dusty In Memphis material are sharper and brighter, but also warmer than the original 1992 CD […] One other nice feature of the new edition is that the clarity of the remastering brings the backing instruments out as never before, which makes one appreciate the production and arrangements as well as her performance. — Bruce Eder
Und aus dem Guardian über die neue Mercury-Edition:
Habitually hailed as the pinnacle of Dusty Springfield’s career (even if she claimed she could never understand what all the fuss was about) and a 1960s white-soul landmark, Dusty in Memphis sparkles afresh in a new deluxe edition from Mercury (*****). […]
This reissue also includes mono mixes of eight of the original tracks, as a reminder of what audio used to be. It’s a priceless fragment of history.
--