The Smiths – The Queen Is Dead – Rolling Stone Forum

Ansicht von 15 Beiträgen - 1 bis 15 (von insgesamt 127)

1 2 … 9 →

Autor

Beiträge
7. Oktober 2004 um 0:08 #18785 | PERMALINK

hank-williams

Registriert seit: 07.04.2004

Beiträge: 3,150

1. The Queen Is Dead **** 1/2
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly ****
3. I Know It's Over *****
4. Never Had No One Ever **** 1/2
5. Cemetry Gates *****
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again *****
7. The Boy With The Thorn In His Side *****
8. Vicar In A Tutu ****
9. There Is A Light That Never Goes Out *****
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others *****

Hmm… rein rechnerisch wären das bei mir „4.7“ – aber was soll's? Ein Album kann bekanntlich mehr als seine bloßen Einzelteile sein, und deshalb runde ich auch einfach mal auf volle fünf Sterne auf.
PS: „Take Me Back To Dear Old Blighty“ bleibt ohne Wertung. B)

--
„Kreuzberg ist so hart, dass sogar die Steine sagen: Wir sind zu weich für die Strasse. So hart ist Kreuzberg.“ (Catee)

Highlights von Rolling-Stone.de
Werbung

7. Oktober 2004 um 0:10 #2408095 | PERMALINK

kink

Registriert seit: 08.11.2002

Beiträge: 9,887

1. The Queen Is Dead *****
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly *****
3. I Know It's Over *****
4. Never Had No One Ever ****
5. Cemetry Gates *****
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again *****
7. The Boy With The Thorn In His Side *****
8. Vicar In A Tutu ****
9. There Is A Light That Never Goes Out *****
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others ****1/2

Schnitt : 4,75

Für mich immer schon ein klarer ***** !

--
"Youth is a wonderful thing. What a crime to waste it on children."

7. Oktober 2004 um 0:13 #2408097 | PERMALINK

candycolouredclown
Moderator

Registriert seit: 08.07.2002

Beiträge: 19,059

Na gut, ich denke ich mach das auch mal…

1. The Queen Is Dead *****
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly *****
3. I Know It's Over *****
4. Never Had No One Ever ****
5. Cemetry Gates ***
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again ****
7. The Boy With The Thorn In His Side ***1/2
8. Vicar In A Tutu *****
9. There Is A Light That Never Goes Out *****
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others ****1/2

Mir egal, was das für ein Schnitt wäre. Bestes Album der 80er und ***** natürlich.

--
Flow like a harpoon daily and nightly

7. Oktober 2004 um 0:14 #2408099 | PERMALINK

kink

Registriert seit: 08.11.2002

Beiträge: 9,887

Originally posted by candycolouredclown@7 Oct 2004, 02:13

Mir egal, was das für ein Schnitt wäre. Bestes Album der 80er und ***** natürlich.

Hier bräuchte man dann das gute alte :twisted: :lol:

--
"Youth is a wonderful thing. What a crime to waste it on children."

7. Oktober 2004 um 1:55 #2408101 | PERMALINK

napoleon-dynamite
Moderator

Registriert seit: 09.11.2002

Beiträge: 21,865

1. The Queen Is Dead *****
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly *****
3. I Know It's Over *****
4. Never Had No One Ever ****
5. Cemetry Gates *****
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again *****
7. The Boy With The Thorn In His Side *****
8. Vicar In A Tutu ****
9. There Is A Light That Never Goes Out *****
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others *****

--
A Kiss in the Dreamhouse

7. Oktober 2004 um 2:02 #2408103 | PERMALINK

kink

Registriert seit: 08.11.2002

Beiträge: 9,887

Originally posted by Napoleon Dynamite@7 Oct 2004, 03:55
1. The Queen Is Dead *****
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly *****
3. I Know It's Over *****
4. Never Had No One Ever ****
5. Cemetry Gates *****
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again *****
7. The Boy With The Thorn In His Side *****
8. Vicar In A Tutu ****
9. There Is A Light That Never Goes Out *****
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others *****

Das sind ja fast 100 % Übereinstimmung , Herr Napoleon. Hast du vor die „Be here now“ zu bewerten ? :lol:

--
"Youth is a wonderful thing. What a crime to waste it on children."

7. Oktober 2004 um 2:05 #2408105 | PERMALINK

napoleon-dynamite
Moderator

Registriert seit: 09.11.2002

Beiträge: 21,865

yeah! moment…

--
A Kiss in the Dreamhouse

7. Oktober 2004 um 4:48 #2408107 | PERMALINK

melodynelson
L'Homme à tête de chou
Registriert seit: 01.03.2004

Beiträge: 6,004

1. The Queen Is Dead *****
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly ****1/2
3. I Know It's Over *****
4. Never Had No One Ever ****
5. Cemetry Gates *****
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again *****
7. The Boy With The Thorn In His Side *****
8. Vicar In A Tutu ****
9. There Is A Light That Never Goes Out *****
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others *****

--

7. Oktober 2004 um 7:38 #2408109 | PERMALINK

declan-macmanus

Registriert seit: 07.01.2003

Beiträge: 14,707

1. The Queen Is Dead *****
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly *****
3. I Know It's Over *****
4. Never Had No One Ever ****1/2
5. Cemetry Gates *****
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again *****
7. The Boy With The Thorn In His Side *****
8. Vicar In A Tutu ****
9. There Is A Light That Never Goes Out *****
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others *****

Schnitt 4,85

Natürlich *****

--
Lately I've been seeing things / They look like they float at the back of my head room[/B] [/SIZE][/FONT]

7. Oktober 2004 um 8:51 #2408111 | PERMALINK

matthias_h

Registriert seit: 16.10.2003

Beiträge: 231

1. The Queen Is Dead ****1/2
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly *****
3. I Know It's Over *****
4. Never Had No One Ever ****
5. Cemetry Gates *****
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again *****
7. The Boy With The Thorn In His Side *****
8. Vicar In A Tutu ****1/2
9. There Is A Light That Never Goes Out *****
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others *****

natürlich *****

--

7. Oktober 2004 um 11:06 #2408113 | PERMALINK

themagneticfield

Registriert seit: 25.04.2003

Beiträge: 34,015

1. The Queen Is Dead *****
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly *****
3. I Know It's Over ***1/2
4. Never Had No One Ever ****
5. Cemetry Gates *****
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again *****
7. The Boy With The Thorn In His Side *****
8. Vicar In A Tutu ***1/2
9. There Is A Light That Never Goes Out *****
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others *****

--
"Man kann nicht verhindern, dass man verletzt wird, aber man kann mitbestimmen von wem. Was berührt, das bleibt!

7. Oktober 2004 um 15:07 #2408115 | PERMALINK

this-charming-man

Registriert seit: 15.01.2003

Beiträge: 78

1. The Queen Is Dead *****
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly *****
3. I Know It's Over *****
4. Never Had No One Ever ****
5. Cemetry Gates *****
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again *****
7. The Boy With The Thorn In His Side *****
8. Vicar In A Tutu ****
9. There Is A Light That Never Goes Out *****
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others *****

Der Schnitt ist egal! Grandioses Fünf-Sterne-Album! Eine der besten Platten aller Zeiten!

--
Die größten Kritiker der Elche waren früher selber welche!

21. Oktober 2004 um 20:46 #2408117 | PERMALINK

sommer
Moderator

Registriert seit: 10.10.2004

Beiträge: 8,302

1. The Queen Is Dead *****
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly *****
3. I Know It's Over ****1/2
4. Never Had No One Ever ****
5. Cemetry Gates ****
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again *****
7. The Boy With The Thorn In His Side *****
8. Vicar In A Tutu ***1/2
9. There Is A Light That Never Goes Out *****
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others *****

summa summarum *****

--

8. November 2004 um 14:29 #2408119 | PERMALINK

Anonym
Inaktiv

Registriert seit: 01.01.1970

Beiträge: 0

1. The Queen Is Dead *****
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly ****
3. I Know It's Over *****
4. Never Had No One Ever *****
5. Cemetry Gates *****
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again *****
7. The Boy With The Thorn In His Side *****
8. Vicar In A Tutu ****
9. There Is A Light That Never Goes Out *****
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others *****

--

14. Dezember 2004 um 7:37 #2408121 | PERMALINK

jimmydean

Registriert seit: 13.11.2003

Beiträge: 3,623

1. The Queen Is Dead ****
2. Frankly, Mr. Shankly ****
3. I Know It's Over ****1/2
4. Never Had No One Ever ****
5. Cemetry Gates *****
6. Bigmouth Strikes Again *****
7. The Boy With The Thorn In His Side *****
8. Vicar In A Tutu ****
9. There Is A Light That Never Goes Out ***** (bester smiths songs)
10. Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others *****

sehr starke zweite seite

--
i don't care about the girls, i don't wanna see the world, i don't care if i'm all alone, as long as i can listen to the Ramones (the dubrovniks)