Man könnte natürlich noch viele Vergleiche anstellen, die in Teilen auch interessant sind. Man darf bei all diesen Vergleichen aber nicht außer Acht lassen, dass die Teilnehmer nicht unwesentlich differieren.
Ich habe nochmal die Auswertung pro Jahrgang genommen und diese der Auswertung der Work in Progress-Jahresthreads gegenübergestellt. Die Top 10 differieren teilweise schon sehr stark. Ist natürlich auch ein ganz anderer Ansatz. (erste Liste: aktuelle Umfrage / zweite Liste: Jahresthread):
2010
01. JOHN GRANT – Queen Of Denmark
02. ARCADE FIRE – The Suburbs
03. MARINA & THE DIAMONDS – The Family Jewels
04. THE NATIONAL – High Violet
05. BEACH HOUSE – Teen Dream
06. LAURA MARLING – I Speak Because I Can
07. KANYE WEST – My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
08. JOANNA NEWSOM – Have One On Me
09. I AM KLOOT – Sky At Night
10. JANELLE MONÁE – The Archandroid
2010 (58 Teilnehmer)
1. The National – High violet
2. Warpaint – The fool
3. The Coral – Butterfly house
4. Kanye West – My beautiful dark twisted fantasy
5. Secret Sisters – Secret Sisters
6. Arcade Fire – The suburbs
7. The See See – Late morning light
8. Joanna Newsom – Have one on me
9. John Grant – Queen of Denmark
10. William Hooker – Earth’s orbit
2011
01. MATANA ROBERTS – Coin Coin Chapter One: Gens De Couleur Libres
02. PJ HARVEY – Let England Shake
03. GILLIAN WELCH – The Harrow And The Harvest
04. BILL CALLAHAN – Apocalypse
05. FLEET FOXES – Helplessness Blues
06. THE BLACK KEYS – El Camino
07. LYKKE LI – Wounded Rhymes
08. SARABETH TUCEK – Get Well Soon
09. EILEN JEWELL – Queen Of The Minor Key
10. MISTY MILLER – The Whole Family Is Worried
2011 (65 Teilnehmer)
1. PJ Harvey – Let England shake
2. Matana Roberts – Coin Coin Chapter One
3. Kurt Vile – Smoke rings for my halo
4. The Black Keys – El Camino
5. Wilco – The whole love
6. The Decemberists – The king is dead
7. Eilen Jewell – Queen of the minor key
8. Bill Callahan – Apocalypse
9. Kate Bush – 50 words for snow
10. Gillian Welch – The harrow and the harvest
2012
01. SCOTT WALKER – Bish Bosch
02. KENDRICK LAMAR – Good Kid, M.A.A.D City
03. ALLAH-LAS – Allah-Las
04. NENEH CHERRY & THE THING – The Cherry Thing
05. SWANS – The Seer
06. FRANK OCEAN – Channel Orange
07. NICK WATERHOUSE – Time’s All Gone
08. NEIL YOUNG & CRAZY HORSE – Psychedelic Pill
09. FIONA APPLE – The Idler Wheel Is Wiser Than The Driver Of The Screw…
10. DEXYS – One Day I’m Going To Soar
2012 (49 Teilnehmer)
1. Neil Young – Psychedelic pill
2. Kendrick Lamar – Good kid, m.a.a.d. city
3. First Aid Kit – The lion’s roar
4. Frank Ocean – Channel orange
5. Bob Dylan – Tempest
6. Beth Orton – Sugaring season
7. Lana Del Rey – Born to die
8. Patti Smith – Banga
9. Crippled Black Phoenix – (Mankind) The crafty ape
10. Bill Fay – Life is people
2013
01. NICK CAVE & THE BAD SEEDS – Push The Sky Away
02. JASON ISBELL – Southeastern
03. DAFT PUNK – Random Access Memories
04. BILL CALLAHAN – Dream River
05. STEVEN WILSON – The Raven That Refused To Sing (And Other Stories)
06. ISRAEL NASH – Israel Nash’s Rain Plans
07. THE NATIONAL – Trouble Will Find Me
08. GOLDFRAPP – Tales Of Us
09. BIG BIG TRAIN – English Electric Part Two
10. ARCADE FIRE – Reflektor
2013 (42 Teilnehmer)
1. Nick Cave – Push the sky away
2. Israel Nash – Rain plans
3. Steven Wilson – The raven that refused to sing
4. Jason Isbell – Southeastern
5. Arcade Fire – Reflektor
6. David Bowie – The next day
7. Big Big Train – English electric Part 2
8. Laura Marling – Once I was an eagle
9. Savages – Silence yourself
10. Vampire Weekend – Modern vampires of the city
2014
01. THE WAR ON DRUGS – Lost In The Dream
02. SUN KIL MOON – Benji
03. D’ANGELO AND THE VANGUARD – Black Messiah
04. TEMPLES – Sun Structures
05. SWANS – To Be Kind
06. IQ – The Road Of Bones
07. SCOTT WALKER + SUNN O))) – Soused
08. RAMONA LISA – Arcadia
09. WANDA – Amore
10. DAMON ALBARN – Everyday Robots
2014 (63 Teilnehmer)
1. The War on Drugs – Lost in the dream
2. Warpaint – Warpaint
3. Marissa Nadler – July
4. Swans – To be kind
5. Angel Olsen – Burn your fire for no witness
6. D’Angelo and the Vanguard – Black Messiah
7. Ryley Walker – All kinds of you
8. IQ – Road of bones
9. Reigning Sound – Shattered
10. Sun Kil Moon – Benji
2015
01. KENDRICK LAMAR – To Pimp A Butterfly
02. SUFJAN STEVENS – Carrie & Lowell
03. KATHRYN JOSEPH – Bones You Have Thrown Me And Blood I’ve Spilled
04. JULIA HOLTER – Have You In My Wilderness
05. JOANNA NEWSOM – Divers
06. STEVEN WILSON – Hand. Cannot. Erase.
07. BENJAMIN CLEMENTINE – At Least For Now
08. BLUR – The Magic Whip
09. NEW ORDER – Music Complete
10. BILL FAY – Who Is The Sender?
2015 (46 Teilnehmer)
1. Julia Holter – Have you in my wilderness
2. Sufjan Stevens – Carrie and Lowell
3. Kendrick Lamar – To pimp a butterfly
4. Steven Wilson – Hand. Cannot. Erase.
5. The Decemberists – What a terrible world, what a beautiful world
6. Kurt Vile – B’lieve I’m going down
7. Benjamin Clementine – At least for now
8. Joanna Newsom – Divers
9. Joe Jackson – Fast forward
10. Ryley Walker – Primrose green
2016
01. DAVID BOWIE – Blackstar
02. RADIOHEAD – A Moon Shaped Pool
03. LEONARD COHEN – You Want It Darker
04. FRANK OCEAN – Blonde
05. DANNY BROWN – Atrocity Exhibition
06. MICHAEL KIWANUKA – Love & Hate
07. BEYONCÉ – Lemonade
08. THE ROLLING STONES – Blue & Lonesome
09. DIE HEITERKEIT – Pop & Tod I + II
10. SHABAKA AND THE ANCESTORS – Wisdom Of Elders
2016 (55 Teilnehmer)
1. David Bowie – Blackstar
2. Nick Cave – Skeleton tree
3. Radiohead – A moon shaped pool
4. Leonard Cohen – You want it darker
5. Beyoncé – Lemonade
6. The Rolling Stones – Blue and lonesome
7. Angel Olsen – My woman
8. Anohni – Hopelessness
9. Swans – The glowing man
10. Michael Kiwanuka – Love and hate
2017
01. VIJAY IYER SEXTET – Far From Over
02. LORDE – Melodrama
03. MOUNT EERIE – A Crow Looked At Me
04. COLTER WALL – Colter Wall
05. THE WAR ON DRUGS – A Deeper Understanding
06. SIMON JOYNER – Step Into The Earthquake
07. KLEZ.E – Desintegration
08. AMBROSE AKINMUSIRE – A Rift In Decorum: Live At The Village Vanguard
09. ANOUAR BRAHEM, DAVE HOLLAND, JACK DeJOHNETTE & DJANGO BATES – Blue Maqams
10. JOE HENRY – Thrum
2017 (99 Teilnehmer)
1. The War On Drugs – A deeper understanding
2. Slowdive – Slowdive
3. Holly Macve – Golden eagle
4. Simon Joyner – Step into the earthquake
5. Kendrick Lamar – DAMN
6. Lorde – Melodrama
7. Colter Wall – Colter Wall
8. Marry Waterson & David A. Jaycock – Death had quicker wings than love
9. St. Vincent – Masseducation
10. Jason Isbell – The Nashville Sound
2018
01. LOW – Double Negative
02. SONS OF KEMET – Your Queen Is A Reptile
03. PHIDEAUX – Infernal
04. JOHN PRINE – The Tree Of Forgiveness
05. ED ROMANOFF – The Orphan King
06. A PERFECT CIRCLE – Eat The Elephant
07. GOAT GIRL – Goat Girl
08. THE PINEAPPLE THIEF – Dissolution
09. KATHRYN JOSEPH – From When I Wake The Want Is
10. INTERNATIONAL MUSIC – Die Besten Jahre
2018 (97 Teilnehmer)
1. Elvis Costello – Look now
2. Kathryn Joseph – From when I wake the want is
3. Janelle Monae – Dirty computer
4. Tocotronic – Die Unendlichkeit
5. Anna & Elizabeth – The invisible comes to us
6. Stick In The Wheel – Follow them true
7. Kurt Vile – Bottle it in
8. Shame – Songs of praise
9. Rolling Blackouts C.F. – Hope downs
10. Low – Double negative
2019
01. IAN NOE – Between The Country
02. LANA DEL REY – Norman Fucking Rockwell!
03. TOOL – Fear Inoculum
04. WEYES BLOOD – Titanic Rising
05. THE DELINES – The Imperial
06. KASSI VALAZZA – Dear Dead Days
07. ANDREW BIRD – My Finest Work Yet
08. KALI MALONE – The Sacrificial Code
09. FONTAINES D.C. – Dogrel
10. NICK CAVE & THE BAD SEEDS – Ghosteen
2019 (103 Teilnehmer)
1. Lana Del Rey – NFR!
2. Purple Mountains – Purple Mountains
3. Nick Cave – Ghosteen
4. Ian Noe – Between the country
5. Billie Eilish – When we all fall asleep where do we go
6. Matana Roberts – Coin Coin Chapter 4: Memphis
7. The Delines – The imperial
8. Weyes Blood – Titanic rising
9. Bruce Springsteen – Western skies
10. Swans – Leaving meaning
--
there's room at the top they are telling you still but first you must learn how to smile as you kill