Scott Walker - Scott

[nikodemus]

Nach der ausführlich Rezi beim WIEDERHÖREN jetzt mal die Songs im TÜV

1. Mathilde *****
2. Montague Terrace *****
3. Angelica *****
4. Lady came from Baltimore *****
5. When Joanna loved me ****
6. My Death ****1/2
7. The Big Hurt ****
8. Such A Small Love *****
9. You're gonna hear from me ****
10. Through a long and sleepless night ****
11. Always Coming Back To You *****
12. Amsterdam *****
------
klarer ***** ohne wenn und aber
Scott for president :D

[Hank Williams]

Mathilde *****
Montague Terrace (In Blue) **** 1/2
Angelica **** 1/2
The Lady Came From Baltimore **** 1/2
When Joanna Loved Me *** 1/2
My Death ****
The Big Hurt ****
Such A Small Love **** 1/2
You’re Gonna Hear From Me ***
Through A Long And Sleepless Night ****
Always Coming Back To You ***
Amsterdam **** 1/2

Für mich vier Sterne.

[Moontear]

1. Mathilde *****
2. Montague Terrace *****
3. Angelica *****
4. Lady came from Baltimore *****
5. When Joanna loved me ****
6. My Death *****
7. The Big Hurt ****
8. Such A Small Love ****
9. You're gonna hear from me ****
10. Through a long and sleepless night ****
11. Always Coming Back To You *****
12. Amsterdam *****

Läßt im Lauf des Albums etwas nach, aber immer noch knappe ***** im Gesamtkontext.

[MichaelCorleone]

Mathilde *****
Montague Terrace (In Blue) *****
Angelica *****
The Lady Came From Baltimore *****
When Joanna Loved Me **** 1/2
My Death *****
The Big Hurt **** 1/2
Such A Small Love *****
You’re Gonna Hear From Me **** 1/2
Through A Long And Sleepless Night ****
Always Coming Back To You *****
Amsterdam *****

4,79, natürlich volle Sternenanzahl. Großen Dank an Herr Rossi der anscheinend den richtigen Riecher hatte und mir Walker empfohl.

[a lad insane]

Mathilde *****
Montague Terrace (In Blue) *****
Angelica **** 1/2
The Lady Came From Baltimore **** 1/2
When Joanna Loved Me ****
My Death *****
The Big Hurt **** 1/2
Such A Small Love **** 1/2
You’re Gonna Hear From Me **** 1/2
Through A Long And Sleepless Night ****
Always Coming Back To You **** 1/2
Amsterdam *****

Im Gesamtkontext *****

[pinch]

Mathilde ****
Montague Terrace (In Blue) ****
Angelica ****1/2
The Lady Came From Baltimore ****1/2
When Joanna Loved Me ****
My Death *****
The Big Hurt ****
Such A Small Love ****
You’re Gonna Hear From Me ****
Through A Long And Sleepless Night ****
Always Coming Back To You ****
Amsterdam ****

[dr.music]

...Klarer ***** ohne wenn und aber

Bei mir ebenso! Für mich seine Beste. TOP250.

[Mark Oliver Everett]

edit.

[asdfjklö]

01. Mathilde *****
02. Montague Terrace *****
03. Angelica *****
04. Lady came from Baltimore *****
05. When Joanna loved me ****1/2
06. My Death ****1/2
07. The Big Hurt ****
08. Such A Small Love *****
09. You're gonna hear from me ****
10. Through a long and sleepless night ****
11. Always Coming Back To You ****
12. Amsterdam *****

[Fagen]

1. Mathilde * * * * *
2. Montague terrace * * * * 1/2
3. Angelica * * * * *
4. Lady came from Baltimore * * * * 1/2
5. When Joanna loved me * * * *
6. My death * * * * 1/2
7. The big hurt * * * * 1/2
8. Such a small love * * * *
9. You're gonna hear from me * * * *
10. Through a long and sleepless night * * * * *
11. Always coming back to you * * * * *
12. Amsterdam * * * *

Gesamtwertung * * * * 1/2

[Systematic Drummer]

Side 1
1. Mathilde * * * * *
2. Montague Terrace (In Blue) * * * * *
3. Angelica * * * * *
4. Lady Came From Baltimore * * * * 1/2
5. When Joanna Loved Me * * * * *
6. My Death * * * * *

Side 2
1. The Big Hurt * * * * *
2. Such A Small Love * * * * 1/2
3. You're Gonna Hear From Me * * * * *
4. Through A Long And Sleepless Night * * * * *
5. Always Coming Back To You * * * * *
6. Amsterdam * * * *

Gesamt: * * * * *

[Yellowsubmarine]

01. Mathilde *****
02. Montague Terrace *****
03. Angelica *****
04. Lady came from Baltimore *****
05. When Joanna loved me ****1/2
06. My Death ****1/2
07. The Big Hurt ****
08. Such A Small Love *****
09. You're gonna hear from me ****
10. Through a long and sleepless night ****
11. Always Coming Back To You ****
12. Amsterdam *****

Genau meine Wertung!!!
Steht auf meiner ewigen Bestenliste....

[Irrlicht]

Für den Drummer:

Erster Wertungsversuch...

1. Mathilde **** 1/2
2. Montague terrace (in blue) **** 1/2
3. Angelica *****
4. The lady came from Baltimore *** 1/2
5. When Joanna loved me *** 1/2
6. My death *****
7. The big hurt *** 1/2
8. Such a small love ****
9. You're gonna hear from me *** 1/2
10. Through a long and sleepless night *** 1/2
11. Always coming back to you *** 1/2
12. Amsterdam *****
---------------------
**** (+)

[Manuel1979]

1. Mathilde *****
2. Montague Terrace *****
3. Angelica ***
4. Lady came from Baltimore ****
5. When Joanna loved me ***1/2
6. My Death *****
7. The Big Hurt **1/2
8. Such A Small Love ***1/2
9. You're gonna hear from me ***
10. Through a long and sleepless night ****
11. Always Coming Back To You *****
12. Amsterdam *****

Song Ranking:
1. My death
2. Always coming back to you
3. Amsterdam

insgesamt * * * * mit Tendenz nach oben!

[Irrlicht]

3. Angelica ***

Das ist wenig, wie kommts?