Ranking der PJ Harvey-Alben

[PatrikTroll]

1. Dry *****
2. White chalk *****
3. Is this desire? *****
4. To bring you my love ****1/2
5. Uh huh her ****
6. Dance hall at Louse Point ***1/2
7. Rid of me ***1/2
8. A woman a man walked by ***
9. Stories from the city, stories from the sea ***

[Xerxes]

1. Rid Of Me
2. 4-Track Demos
3. Dry
4. Is This Desire?
5. Uh Huh Her
6. Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea
7. To Bring You My Love
8. Dance Hall At Louise Point
9. White Chalk
10.A Woman A Man Walked By

1-3: * * * *
4-7: * * * 1/2
8-10: * * *

[foe]

01. Dry *****
02. To Bring You My Love
03. Uh Huh Her
04. Is This Desire? ****1/2
05. White Chalk
06. Rid Of Me ****
07. Stories From The City Stories From The Sea
08. 4-Track Demos ***1/2
09. A Woman A Man Walked By
10. Dance Hall At Louse Point

[Carrot Flower]

1. White Chalk *****
2. To Bring You My Love *****
3. Dry *****
4. Is This Desire ****½
5. Rid Of Me ****
6. Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea ****
7. Uh Huh Her ***½
8. 4-Track Demos ***½
9. A Woman A Man Walked By***

Und, ihr Lieben, ihr meint Louse Point :-)

[( 0 M A]

To Bring You My Love *****
Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea *****
Is This Desire? *****
Dry **** 1/2
Rid Of Me ****
White Chalk ****

[Jan Lustiger]

hatte noch versprochen, hier vorbeizuschauen:

1. White Chalk *****
2. Is This Desire? ****1/2
3. Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea ****1/2
4. To Bring You My Love ****
5. Dry ****
6. Rid Of Me ***1/2
7. Uh Huh Her ***

Die Alben mit John Parish ziehe ich in die reguläre PJ-Diskographie nicht mit ein, habe davon auch nur "A Woman A Man Walked By" (***1/2). 5 von 7 Alben mit mindestens **** ist jedenfalls eine sehr gute Bilanz.

[Moxy Rusic]

1. To Bring You My Love *****
2. Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea ****
3. Uh Huh Her ***1/2
4. Is This Desire? ***
5. Dry ***

TO BRING YOU MY LOVE stimmt von vorne bis hinten, STORIES find ich sehr kraftvoll, UH HUH + DESIRE zeitweise zerbrechlich. Mit DRY werde ich (immer noch nicht) warm

Muß immer wieder feststellen, daß die ersten erworbenen Alben der Künstler oftmals den nachhaltigsten Eindruck hinterlassen. Anders herum gefragt: hätte man sich die Alben in einer anderen Reihenfolge zugelegt, wäre dann Nr. 1 still number one !?

[MichaelCorleone]

1. Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea **** 1/2
2. Is This Desire? **** 1/2
3. To Bring You My Love ****
4. Dry *** 1/2
5. Rid of Me ** 1/2
6. Dance Hall At Louise Point ** 1/2

[Natsume]

1. Is This Desire? (1998)
2. To Bring You My Love (1995)
3. White Chalk (2007)
4. 4-Track Demos (1993)
5. Dry (1992)
6. Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea (2000)
7. Uh Huh Her (2004)
8. Rid Of Me (1993)




Die Alben mit John Parish ziehe ich in die reguläre PJ-Diskographie nicht mit ein, [...]

So ist's fein.

[Jan Lustiger]

1. White Chalk *****
2. Is This Desire? ****1/2
3. Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea ****1/2
4. To Bring You My Love ****
5. Dry ****
6. Rid Of Me ***1/2
7. Uh Huh Her ***

Erweiterungszeit:
1. White Chalk *****
2. Is This Desire? ****½
3. Let England Shake ****½
4. Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea ****½
5. To Bring You My Love ****
6. Dry ****
7. Rid Of Me ***½
8. Uh Huh Her ***

[foe]

01. Dry *****
02. To Bring You My Love
03. Uh Huh Her
04. Is This Desire? ****1/2
05. White Chalk
06. Rid Of Me ****
07. Stories From The City Stories From The Sea
08. 4-Track Demos ***1/2
09. A Woman A Man Walked By
10. Dance Hall At Louse Point

01. Dry *****
02. To Bring You My Love
03. Uh Huh Her
04. Let England Shake
05. Is This Desire? ****½
06. White Chalk
07. Rid Of Me ****
08. Stories From The City Stories From The Sea
09. 4-Track Demos ***½


01. A Woman A Man Walked By ***½
02. Dance Hall At Louse Point